Document Type : Research Paper
Author
Assistant Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Research Institute of Cultural Heritage and Tourism, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
The variant readings khayr qabūl and khayr va qabūl in the couplet “Ān javānbakht ki mīzad raqam-i khayr va qabūl / Banda-yi pīr nadānam zi chi āzād nakard” present a disputed problem in the textual criticism and interpretation of Hafez’s poetry. Adopting a descriptive-analytical approach, this study examines manuscript, historical, linguistic, and rhetorical evidence to determine the preferable textual form and assess its competing grammatical and semantic interpretations. The Nuruosmaniye manuscript dated 801 AH, together with the variants documented by Salim Neysari, provides stronger manuscript support for the form without the conjunction va (“and”). Nevertheless, this unvocalized form does not, in itself, establish the ezafe reading khayr-i qabūl, since it may also be interpreted as khayr qabūl, a proposed formula of acceptance. A critical examination of previous interpretations identifies difficulties concerning historical attestation, grammatical plausibility, or semantic coherence. The association between khayr (“good” or “charitable action”) and qabūl (“acceptance”) in the poetry of Adib Saber, and the ezafe construction hajj-i qabūl in Hafez’s own poetry, offer linguistic and semantic grounds for considering khayr-i qabūl plausible, although neither directly attests the exact expression. Furthermore, the contrast between javānbakht (“young and fortunate”) and banda-yi pīr (“aged servant”), together with the imagery of seeking justice in the following couplet, reveals a rhetorical movement from apparent praise to implicit reproach and grievance. The findings indicate that the conjunctionless form khayr qabūl is preferable on manuscript grounds, whereas the ezafe interpretation khayr-i qabūl remains a cautiously favored reading supported by converging linguistic and contextual evidence rather than direct historical attestation. The study thus underscores the methodological importance of distinguishing textual variants from grammatical interpretations and of recognizing the evidential limits of each type of source in Hafezian textual criticism.
Keywords
Main Subjects